Is Bitcoin Haram Or Halal Under Islamic Finance?

Lost money to a crypto or trading scam? Read this first:

If your losses exceed £3,000 (in the UK) or $10,000 worldwide The Crypto Adviser can offer advice on recovering your funds. 

>> GET IN TOUCH

When it comes to Islamic finance and Bitcoin, there is much debate over whether the cryptocurrency is halal (permitted) or haram (forbidden), and whether it’s Sharia compliant.

As cryptocurrency has gained popularity, scholars across the Muslim world have been closely examining Bitcoin to analyse its compatibility with Islamic principles.

Here, I’ll examine some of the key discussion points surrounding Bitcoin, the most well-known centralised digital currency, and how it stands with Islamic finance.

For those of you pressed for time, here’s a quick answer which reflects much of the published opinion:

The short answer is Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining is likely to be considered Halal, depending on the specific circumstances around its purchase and use.

Is Bitcoin Haram?

Islamic finance is guided by Sharia, which is the ethical principles derived from the Quran.

Haram literally means forbidden and in the finance world applies to such areas as gambling and speculation.

Other key principles include Riba, which relates to interest on investments, and Gharar, which applies to the uncertainty that may exist in a contract.

Potential issues with Bitcoin and Islamic finance

Speculation

The principles of Islamic finance discourage speculation and gambling-like behaviour.

Many people who invest in Bitcoin do so because they are speculating that the price will increase in the future, or that they can take advantage of the crypto’s notorious price volatility.

This automatically raises concerns regarding its compliance with Islamic principles if a Muslim were to undertake this activity.

Some Scholars argue that Bitcoin’s speculative nature makes it Haram as it aligns with prohibited gambling practices.

Riba

Bitcoin on its own does not involve any element of interest.

However, it’s often used by lending and borrowing platforms where interest is charged on the transactions and paid to lenders.

This could be seen as violating the principle of Riba.

Gharar

While the technology that Bitcoin is based on ensures transparency through the public ledger known as the blockchain, some argue that its volatile price movements introduce an element of Gharar.

This fluctuating value presents challenges when it comes to determining a fair exchange rate which could potentially lead to contractual disputes involving Bitcoin.

Illegal activities

Activities such as money laundering and taking part in any other form of illicit transaction is condemned by Islamic finance.

The pseudonymous nature of Bitcoin and its association with criminal behaviour does contradict Islamic principles, yet Bitcoin itself is not inherently illicit.

The manner in which it’s used determines whether it’s compliant with Shariah rules or not.

Scholarly opinion on whether Bitcoin is Haram

Whether Bitcoin is Haram is still up for debate, with Islamic Scholars expressing a wide range of opinions regarding the permissibility of Bitcoin among Muslims.

Some argue that as Bitcoin is not issued or controlled by any central authority such as a Government, it is considered a commodity and can be traded in the same way as gold or silver which is permitted, this making it Halal for trading.

However, others stand by the argument that the very nature of investing in Bitcoin is speculative and that its lack of intrinsic value and the potential for use in illegal activities makes it non-compliant with the principles of Islamic finance.

Is Bitcoin mining Haram or Halal?

Bitcoin mining is the process in which news coins are created and transactions are verified and entered onto the decentralised public ledger using a global network of powerful computers.

From an Islamic finance point of view, there are various things to consider:

• Legality and compliance. Bitcoin mining is generally not forbidden in Islamic countries.
• Lending or borrowing. Mining does not involve either of these transactions, so it may not fall into the category of Riba.
• Mining and speculation. Bitcoin mining does not directly contribute to speculation since it is a technical process aimed at securing the network.
• Moral and ethical considerations. Mining Bitcoin uses vast amounts of energy and concerns have been raised about its environmental impact and the compatibility of this with Islamic teachings. As such, the excessive energy usage may be seen as wasteful, contrasting with the principle of Ihsan (moderation).
• Legitimate activity. Islam encourages productive economic activities that make a positive contribution to society. Mining involves maintaining the integrity of the blockchain could be considered a legitimate economic activity in line with Islamic principles.

Bitcoin mining is another area of the cryptosphere that requires a nuanced understanding of Islamic principles during consideration.

It could be argued that if Bitcoin mining adheres to legal and ethical considerations it may be considered Halal.

However, ongoing concerns about the environmental impact of Bitcoin mining must be considered alongside the principles of moderation and sustainability.

Conclusion

Deciding whether Bitcoin is Haram or Halal is a complex area which is the subject of an evolving discussion within the Islamic finance community.

While Bitcoin’s disruptive, innovative technology appeals to many, its standing alongside the principles of Islamic finance has yet to be fully decided.

The prohibition of Riba, Gharar and the link with illicit behaviours pose challenges to the acceptance of Bitcoin within the Muslim world.

If you’re a Muslim and are unclear about whether Bitcoin is Haram or Halal, you should consult with a knowledgeable scholar and carefully weigh up the arguments they present.

There’s also a research piece here and here which you may find useful as part of your decision making process.

Hopefully you’ll be able to make an informed decision based on this advice on whether you can trade Bitcoin or invest in cryptocurrency.

If you need help or advice with any aspect of cryptocurrency, we can help. See our advice services page for more.